Back

Investor Pro

Morningstar Australia · Two paid products into one

I was the product designer on a team of nine at Morningstar Australia. My audit and comparisons helped the team see how much our two paid research products overlapped, and we designed one product with five membership levels. Four modules were built and released before I left, and in sessions I ran with advisers and investors the new Screener scored 88 on the System Usability Scale, against 69 and 59 for the two existing products. This is the full case study. If you are short on time, read the short version.

Investor Pro: the Screener results table in front of the plans page, with smaller pieces around them: a download failed message, an empty watchlist, an actions menu, an allocation bar and a price sparkline
My role
Senior Designer, covering workshops, discovery, design and testing
Company
Morningstar
Team
Cross-functional team of nine
Market
Australia
Timeline
Aug 2025 to Jul 2026

At a glance

The challenge
Growth was in single digits, 6% for ARC and 8% for Morningstar Investor, and trending down. Three research platforms served advisers and investors with overlapping content, each with its own navigation, tools and sign-up path, and they were costly to run.
What I did
Ran discovery end to end, then designed the membership levels, the sign-up flow and the screens for Investor Pro, the new unified product.
Where it landed
One product with five membership levels, a navigation structure proposed from user research, a shorter path from visitor to member, and more than 100 screens on one design system. The System Usability Scale score rose from 59 to 88, and the Net Promoter Score from 29 to 67.
  • 3 → 1platforms brought into one product
  • 5membership levels, from visitor to enterprise
  • 100+screens, at three screen sizes
  • 370+components in one shared library
  • 59 → 88System Usability Scale, old Screener to new
  • 29 → 67Net Promoter Score

01 · Challenge

What the product does

Morningstar is an independent investment research company. Its Australian subscription, Morningstar Investor, gives people who manage their own money analyst research and ratings, tools to find and compare investments, and a way to track a portfolio. Advisers get the same research through a separate product. Investor Pro is the new product that brings them together in one platform.

Research

Know what to buy

Analyst reports and ratings on shares, funds and ETFs.

Tools

Find and compare

Screener, watchlists, alerts and side-by-side comparison.

Portfolio

Track what you hold

Portfolio tracking, X-ray analysis and reporting.

Editorial

Stay informed

Market news, personal finance and guides to investing.

Three platforms, one audience

Morningstar's research offering in Australia sat on three separate platforms: two paid products, ARC and Investor, and the public site, DFD.

01

ARC

A research landscape for advisers: investment research, portfolio research and analyst insights.

02

Investor

Supports logged-in investors with research, tools to track and manage portfolios, and learning.

03

DFD

Supports visitors, and drives acquisition through marketing and SEO.

They served similar core needs, but operated as separate products rather than one unified experience, with separate teams and separate technology behind them.

The problem

We worked with stakeholders to reach a single statement the whole team could point to.

Problem statement

Our research platforms were designed to support both professional advisers and individual investors with market insights, portfolio research, reporting and tools. While they serve similar core needs, they operate as separate products rather than a unified experience, and they are no longer meeting their goals for user growth, retention and operational efficiency.

Four things were driving it:

How we framed it: four questions with stakeholders

Before proposing anything, we needed a shared view of the problem. We worked through four questions with stakeholders, captured the answers on sticky notes, and looked for what they had in common.

Question 1

What are the current goals of the products?

Give advisers and investors a way to research the market, get insights, and track and manage their portfolios.

Question 2

What problem do stakeholders want addressed?

Products serving the same purpose for different users, duplicated technology stacks, and an ageing adviser product.

Question 3

Which goals aren't being met?

Two teams looking after two products with very similar features isn't sustainable. We don't know our users well enough, personalisation is limited, there is no AI assistance for research, and new experiences are slow to reach the market.

Question 4

What is the request, without dictating a solution?

Consolidate down to one product. Show the value we offer, help users achieve their goals, and bring price tiering in line with market standards.

FigJam board with the problem statement at the top and four questions below it, each answered with sticky notes from stakeholders
The problem statement, and the four questions and answers it came from

The opportunity

Opportunity statement

There is an opportunity to unify our research platforms to deliver a more consistent experience across advisers and investors, improving engagement, retention and revenue while reducing operational complexity.

By reducing fragmentation, consolidating overlapping capabilities and improving personalisation, we could increase engagement and retention while improving operational efficiency and supporting sustainable growth.

How might we streamline our research platforms to deliver a more consistent and cohesive experience for both advisers and investors, so that we reduce fragmentation and duplication while improving engagement, retention and revenue growth? How might we

A shared core, with differences by level

Partway through discovery the team decided to consolidate, so the framing workshop was not about adviser and investor as separate products. It was about defining a shared core, and the differences by entitlement.

Whiteboard with handwritten notes on the opportunity, the problem and the challenge
The workshop whiteboard: the opportunity, the problem and the challenge
The open questions and workstreams we started with

Open questions we had to answer

  • Where does the line sit between investor-level workflows and adviser-level capability?
  • How should tiers differ: by throttling, by packaging, or by feature sets?
  • How do advisers buy, get billed for, and get access to the product?
  • What are the gaps between today's products and the unified platform?

Design workstreams

  • Investor UX and UI
  • Transition to the global UX
  • Buying journey
  • Log-in journey
  • Tool integration, uplifting the current tools

02 · Role

My role

I was the designer on the project, responsible for workshops, discovery, design and testing. I oversaw all the design journeys and workflows and the look and feel, validated the design as it took shape, and ran workshops to keep the project on track.

A cross-functional team

We started with a roles and responsibilities session. Each person wrote down what they were responsible for and how they would contribute, using the RACI model (responsible, accountable, consulted, informed), so ownership was clear before the work began.

FigJam board from the roles and responsibilities session, with RACI definitions and sticky notes from each team member
The roles and responsibilities session: what each person is responsible for, and how they contribute
The six functions on the team

Business

Growth and delivery

Accountable for a growing, scalable business and for the success of delivery.

Product

Packaging, pricing and value

Packaging, pricing and value proposition, with expertise in audience and analytics.

Domain

Adviser and investor expertise

Subject-matter experts across both segments, and the voice of the adviser.

Engineering

Technical delivery

Coordinating delivery, keeping ideas dev-ready, and hitting milestones.

Architecture

Technology choices

Technology validation and selection, solution building and architecture.

Design

Experience (my role)

Workshops, discovery, design and testing across every journey.

03 · The product

What we had: an audit of six sites

You can't unify what you haven't mapped. Before designing anything new, I audited the existing estate on one board: the site map of every site, the journeys between them, the tools each product offers, and how Morningstar's sites in other markets solve the same problems.

6

sites mapped, in Australia and globally

~400

navigation items catalogued

3

other markets reviewed: UK, France, Sweden

The full audit board: site maps on the left, site journeys, a tools and offering comparison, screenshots of global sites, and card sort labels
The audit board: site maps, site journeys, tools comparison, global sites and card-sort labels

Three sites, three ways of organising the same things

Laid side by side, the three Australian sites turned out to be organised on three different principles, even though much of the content underneath is shared.

Public site · by topic

morningstar.com.au

  • Markets
  • Investments
  • News and Insights
  • Learn
  • Products
  • Solutions

Investor · by task

Premium

  • Monitor Markets
  • Track Investments
  • Discover Investments
  • Stay Informed
  • Learn to Invest

Adviser · by asset class

ARC

  • Shares
  • Funds
  • Super
  • ETFs
  • LICs
  • Tools

Someone moving from the public site to a subscription, or from one product to the other, had to learn a new mental model each time. A unified platform needs one.

Three site maps side by side for the public site, the Premium investor site and ARC, each a tree of navigation items several levels deep
Site maps of the three Australian sites, side by side

Where the tools actually live

I compared content and tools across five Morningstar sites and products. Editorial and research are everywhere. The tools are not.

CapabilityMorningstar.comMorningstar.com.auInvestor USInvestor AUGlobal UK
Content
Market charts●○○○○
Editorial and opinion●●●●●
Investment research●●●●●
Investment ratings○○●●●
Tools and features
Watchlist○○●●●
Alerts○○ Email●○
Screener○○●●●
Portfolio tracking and management○○● Via Sharesight○
Portfolio analysis (X-ray)○○●●○
Reporting○○○● View only

How people move through it today

I mapped the current subscription flow for Australia and the global site, as swimlanes and then with real screens. In Australia the path to paid takes eight steps and ends on a different site. It also has no registered free member, which the global site does. That gap became the second level of the membership model.

The current flow in Australia, the same flow with real screens, and the global flow
Questions the audit raised
  • Where should free, public content live once the products are unified?
  • How do we give people one login and one sign-up, instead of one per site?
  • How do we avoid confusing free and premium experiences, and manage what each tier can access?
  • How do we protect search visibility when sites move or merge?

04 · The market

Where Morningstar stands

I conducted capability and competitive analysis across research, data, editorial, investment, execution and membership experiences to identify opportunities for consolidation and differentiation.

Capabilities, side by side

The comparison put Morningstar Investor next to 30 other products an Australian investor might use instead, and scored each one across six areas: traffic, research, data, editorial and features, investment products and trade execution, and membership.

17

analysts, the most of the 31 products compared

4,800

securities under analyst research: 1,600 stocks, 3,000 funds and 200 ETFs

150k+

securities with data: 148,350 stocks, 3,061 funds and 362 ETFs

Capabilities comparison table: Morningstar Investor and 30 other products in rows, with columns for traffic, qualitative research, quantitative data, editorial and features, investment products and trade execution, and membership
The capabilities comparison. Morningstar Investor is the highlighted row.

The best research, a fraction of the audience

Put the analyst numbers next to the traffic numbers and the real problem appears. The Motley Fool has 5 analysts and 2.2 million visits a month. Morningstar has 17 analysts and 338 thousand.

Analysts on staff Products with none are not shown

  • Morningstar 17
  • InvestSmart 9
  • The Motley Fool 5
  • Australian Stock Report 5
  • Kalkine 2
  • Simply Wall St 2
  • Barefoot Investor 1

Visits per month Selected research, data and tools products

  • Simply Wall St 5M
  • The Motley Fool 2.2M
  • Market Index 1.9M
  • Investing.com 507.5K
  • Livewire 375.8K
  • Morningstar 337.6K
  • InvestSmart 245.6K
Figures as of April 2024. Visit data from SimilarWeb, March 2024.

The quality of the research was never the issue. Too few people reach it. That is the case for the first two membership levels: give visitors and free members real value, so the research has an audience to convert.

One price, where others offer a range

Morningstar Investor has a single annual price. Most subscription competitors publish a range, with an entry point far below it.

Morningstar also offers no trade execution or investment products. That is a boundary, not a gap: the platform is for research, and trading is the brokers' territory. Pricing is the opening, and it is the one the membership levels are designed to fill.

The competitor landscape

We mapped 27 players on two axes: from broker platforms to research and insights, and from news and editorial to tools and data. It covers everywhere an investor might go instead: a broker, a newspaper, a data site, a research service.

Competitor landscape A map of 27 companies on two axes: broker platforms to research and insights, and news and editorial to tools and data. Morningstar sits in the research and insights, tools and data quadrant, which is the most crowded. NEWS AND EDITORIALTOOLS AND DATA BROKER PLATFORMSRESEARCH AND INSIGHTS Stockhead Bloomberg Financial Review Financial Times Sydney Morning Herald The Motley Fool★ Livewire Rask★ Australian Stock Report★ CMC Markets nabtrade◆ Westpac◆ CommSec◆ Betashares◆ Stockspot IG Small Caps★ Kalkine★ Intelligent Investor★ MarketWatch Investing.com★ Stockopedia★ Yahoo Finance Market Index★ Moneysmart Morningstar★◆ Simply Wall St★
★ Product providers ◆ Targeting both the adviser and investor market
The competitor landscape, redrawn from the original analysis

What the map shows

Where Investor stood

The analysis started with an honest look at the Investor product: what it already did well, where it fell short, and where the market was moving.

Strengths

  • Analyst research and exclusive reports
  • Extensive tools and features
  • Sharesight portfolio manager
  • Personal finance editorial offering
  • Sponsorships and advertising

Weaknesses

  • Product communication and positioning to the market
  • Landing page lacks product promotion
  • Excessive provision of free material
  • Poor UI

Opportunities

  • Surface the value proposition on the public site
  • Tiered pricing structure with control and limitation
  • Partnerships with third parties
  • Enhanced UI and UX
  • Redefine the product proposition

Threats

  • Competitor offerings are superior in key areas
  • Competitors' software focus enables fast-paced improvements and new feature rollout

From weakness to opportunity

Read side by side, the weaknesses and opportunities pair up, and each pair points at design work.

05 · The users

Who we were designing for

In a personas and packaging workshop we sorted the audience into five groups, from people who read for free to professionals using the research inside planning software. The professional groups want what a self-directed investor wants, for many other people. So the board asks: should they be combined?

Whiteboard from the personas and packaging workshop, listing five user groups from individual readers to professionals using financial planning software, with the challenge: should they be combined?
The personas and packaging workshop: five groups and one challenge
The two ends of the range: new investors and advisers

New investors

"How do I do it?"

Their journey starts outside the product: a search engine, an AI chatbot, the news, a friend or family member. They compare and screen stocks, question what to invest in, and often can't decide.

Advisers

Advice they can stand behind

They work through compliance red tape to give good advice, need proof to respond to complaints about that advice, and need research they can trust.

What users told us

The audit showed how the sites were organised. Research showed how people expect them to be organised. I ran two studies: a navigation test, to measure how well people can find things, and a card sort, to learn how investors and advisers group content.

Study one: navigation testing

27 investors were given seven realistic tasks and asked where in the navigation they would go. They worked on their own, with nothing but the menu labels to guide them.

36%

overall task success, against a 70% benchmark

74%

directness: people went straight to their answer

1 of 7

tasks met the benchmark

People navigated with confidence, but to the wrong place. It is a labelling problem, not a structure problem. The key finding

Task success rate 27 participants · dashed line marks the 70% benchmark

  • Find a specific podcast episode 4%
  • Register for an upcoming webinar 19%
  • Find a low-risk investment that pays income 22%
  • Remove investments from a tracked list 33%
  • Find the latest fund research 37%
  • Browse educational content on strategies 59%
  • Look up upcoming dividends 74%
Success by task. Only "upcoming dividends", a concrete label in the user's own words, met the benchmark.
From the findability report: the summary and the per-task results

Study two: the card sort

Investors and advisers sorted the same 28 cards into categories, so we could compare how each group thinks. Every card was a real label from the sites I had audited, such as "Screener", "Watchlists" and "Your Money Weekly", so people were sorting the words they actually see. One question sat behind the study: does a platform for both audiences need role-based navigation?

36

investors completed the card sort

5

financial advisers, a small sample, so directional only

28

cards, sorted into 5 categories or their own

01

Markets is the most stable category

Both groups placed Markets content consistently and without ambiguity.

02

Investments versus Research is the core problem

Both groups described the same confusion, independently and in their own words.

03

A Learn category emerged unprompted

People in both groups asked for a dedicated education space without being offered one.

04

Two different mental models

Advisers are research-first and think in professional workflows. Investors are news-first and think in content types.

How the cards clustered across all 41 participants: the dendrogram, and the similarity matrix where a darker cell means more people put those two cards in the same group

06 · The risks

Risks & premortem

Before committing to the plan, we ran a premortem. The premise: the unified platform has launched, and it has failed. What went wrong? Everyone wrote down their reasons, we grouped them into themes, and the team voted on the ones that worried them most.

36

ways the project could fail, raised by the team

3

themes they grouped into

38

votes cast to find the biggest worries

FigJam board with three groups of sticky notes from the premortem, marked with thumbs-up, star and plus-one votes
The premortem board: market adaptation, tooling and product value, development and integration

Three themes

15 notes

Adapting to the market

Tiers that aren't different enough. Taking too long to reach the market. Subscribers worn out by migration. A competitor launching something that makes us obsolete.

10 notes

Tooling and product value

Advisers without enough pro tooling, feeling undervalued in a tool shared with investors. Investors overwhelmed. Unclear value, and free-trial users who never convert.

11 notes

Development and integration

Teams building in silos. Requirements that keep changing. Chasing feature parity instead of being better. Trying to build everything for everyone.

What worried the team most

Six areas of risk

I framed what came out of the premortem as user and business risks across six areas.

  • MigrationAudience drops during migration, and subscribers tire of change
  • AdoptionFree-trial confusion, and users who never convert
  • Tier valueTiers too similar; throttling pushes basic users away
  • Technical constraintsSiloed builds, and packaging that must stay flexible as strategy changes
  • Competitive positioningCompetitors launch a new experience first
  • Natural-language interactionPeople expect to ask, not navigate, and to read summaries, not articles

The risk that reaches furthest

Two notes described the same future. If development takes too long, people will have become used to asking AI in plain language instead of operating tools themselves: no navigation, and summaries instead of articles. That risk is reflected later in the experience vision, where AI is an embedded layer across the product rather than a feature.

How the top risks changed the plan

The premortem did not stay on the board. Each of the risks the team voted highest changed something in the design.

Charting the course

The premortem told us how the project could fail. To turn that into a plan, we put everything on one picture using the sailboat exercise: the island is the goal, the anchor is what slows us down, the rocks are risks on the horizon, and the sun is the opportunity. The question at the top of the board: what helps us ship one product across three tiers?

FigJam sailboat board: a boat sailing towards an island marked Goal, with an anchor labelled What slows us down, rocks labelled Risks on the horizon, and a sun labelled Opportunities, each with sticky notes
The sailboat board. The anchor carries the risks forward from the premortem.
A clean, unified experience where both investors and advisers feel "this is built for me." The goal, from the board

The island

Goal

Reduce friction across the learn → research → build → analyse workflow for every user. A versatile platform for both audiences that doesn't devalue either, and a soft transition for existing ARC users.

The sun

Opportunity

AI workflows, journeys, summaries and ratings outputs, layered into the overall product and experience.

The rocks

Risks on the horizon

Paid doesn't feel valuable once you sign in. Free tools turn out better than paid ones. The paid experience looks and feels different. Current users are disrupted, and the downgrade path is unclear.

The anchor

What slows us down

The risks from the premortem, plus three new ones: day-to-day operational drag, a scope that isn't clearly defined, and dependence on the global site.

What it changed for design

07 · Strategy

From evidence to decisions

Four kinds of evidence (the product, the market, the users and the risks) each pointed at a decision. This is the thread that runs through everything that follows.

SourceWhat we foundWhat we decided
AuditThree sites organise the same content in three different ways: by topic, by task and by asset class.One navigation for everyone, built from how users group things.
Flow mappingAustralia has no registered free member. People are anonymous, on a trial, or paying.A free member level. Register once and keep the account, whether or not you pay.
Navigation test74% of people go straight to an answer, but only 36% get it right. They are confident and wrong.Keep the structure. Rewrite the labels in the user's language.
Market17 analysts, the most of 31 products, but a fraction of competitors' traffic and a single price.Membership levels instead of one price, with depth that grows with the user.
Card sortAdvisers are research-first. Investors are news-first.One shared foundation with role-based depth. Role-based navigation stays an open question until more advisers are tested.
PremortemThe team's top worry: the tiers won't feel different enough.Every tier gets its own design objectives and its own measure of success.

One product, five levels

One product serves different user types through access levels, and the first version from the workshop read Free trial → Investor → Adviser.

As the evidence came in, the levels settled into visitor, free member and paid member, with the paid level offered at two depths: Premium and Pro. The designs add Enterprise on top, for advice practices that manage Pro access and product lists for their advisers.

01

One product

A single platform instead of separate products for each audience.

02

Five levels

Visitor, Free, Premium, Pro and Enterprise.

03

One shared UX foundation

The same core experience for everyone.

04

Role-based depth & features

What changes between tiers is depth, not the product.

Before: three separate platforms

ARCResearch and editorial content for advisers
InvestorResearch, editorial content and tools for investors
DFDVisitors, marketing and SEO

After: one product, five levels

Visitor
Free
Premium
Pro
Enterprise

One shared UX foundation: Screener · Watchlist · Compare · Portfolio X-ray

The plan: research and editorial content for both user types, in one product with depth set by level

A day in the life, by tier

"One product, five levels" is a business model. To turn it into an experience, we described a day in the life of a modern investor at each tier: what they are thinking, what the design has to do for them, and how we would know it worked.

Core narrative

The product evolves with the user, from discovery to validation to decision to action, with increasing depth, personalisation and intelligence at each tier.

FigJam board titled A day in the life of a modern investor, with a core narrative, five principles, and a column for each user tier
The day-in-the-life framework on the board

Five principles

01

Progressive value, not fragmentation

Users should feel like they are unlocking more power, not switching products.

02

Action-oriented research

Move from static content, to guided decisions, to intelligent recommendations.

03

AI as an embedded layer, not a feature

AI supports discovery, comparison, summarisation and decision framing.

04

Personalisation becomes the product

From generic, to tailored, to predictive.

05

Trust and transparency at every step

Clear methodology, explainability and auditability, which are critical for Australian investors.

The journey by tier

Each tier starts from a different mindset, so each has its own design objectives and its own measure of success.

Visitor

Anonymous user

"I'm exploring. Can I trust this? Is this relevant to me?"

Discovers insight → prompted to explore

  • Drive immediate value without friction
  • Guide to a first action
  • Show the power of the full product
  • Build trust quickly

Primary KPIConversion to free account

Free

Registered user

"I want to try this properly. Is it useful for me?"

Starts tracking → builds a habit

  • Introduce personalisation
  • Create habit loops
  • Enable light tools
  • Introduce AI as a utility
  • Position the upgrade naturally

Primary KPIEngagement and Premium upgrade

Premium

Active investor

"I'm actively managing my investments. Help me make better decisions."

Makes decisions → optimises portfolio

  • Turn insight into decision support
  • Make the portfolio the core hub
  • Elevate AI to a co-pilot
  • Surface opportunities
  • Reduce cognitive load

Primary KPIRetention and deeper usage

Pro

Advanced · SMSF · power users

"I need professional-grade tools. Speed, depth and control matter."

Runs a system → operates like a professional

  • Deliver a true research workspace
  • Enable deep customisation
  • Make AI a strategic partner
  • Unify research and action
  • Support scale and complexity

Primary KPIHigh-value retention

AI grows with the user

AI is not one feature switched on at a price point. It starts as a utility for free users ("Summarise this stock"), becomes a co-pilot for Premium investors ("What should I rebalance?"), and a strategic partner for Pro ("Stress test against inflation").

Moments, not pages

We anchored the designs around five moments in an investor's decision, rather than around pages.

  1. 1Discovery"Is this investment worth my time?"
  2. 2Understanding"What does this actually mean for me?"
  3. 3Comparison"Which option is better?"
  4. 4Decision"What should I do next?"
  5. 5Monitoring"Is my strategy still working?"

One navigation: the proposed structure

Together the studies pointed to six categories, each with a level of confidence from the data.

Proposed information architecture slide: six categories with each item's level of agreement between investors and advisers
The proposed information architecture, with agreement levels for every item

What it means for the design

What the findings changed in the screens

The proposed structure became the navigation that every screen in the design chapter is built on. Six things carried across directly.

Objective & key results

Objective

Deliver a more consistent and cohesive research experience across platforms for both advisers and investors, improving how users access insights, conduct research and manage portfolios.

The objective was tied to five key results, measured in the order they were expected to move: operational complexity first, then the user outcomes that follow from a better product. The target across them was double-digit growth in subscriptions and revenue.

How each level would be judged

Each membership level also carried one primary measure, so the team could see where the product was working and where it was not.

08 · Design

A new path to membership

With the current flow mapped and the research in, I designed the proposed flow at three levels of detail. The task flow follows the person through nine stages and does not stop at payment: activation, onboarding and retention are part of the same journey. The wire flow turns those stages into a system with three membership levels. The visual flow lays it over real screens, to check that every step has a page to live on.

Board titled Proposed User Flow showing three versions side by side: a task flow, a wire flow and a visual flow
The proposed user flow at three levels of detail
The nine stages in detail
  • 01ArriveLands without an account, looking up an investment, or following a search result or shared link. Sees limited access and teasers.
  • 02PaywallMeets the paywall at a moment of intent: opening an analyst report, saving a screener filter, trying X-Ray, viewing detailed fund ratings.
  • 03RegistrationCreates an account. Social login as an optional pattern.
  • 04VerificationVerifies by email or mobile.
  • 05Plan selectionChooses monthly, or annual at a reduced price.
  • 06CheckoutTrial conditions, renewal date and cancellation policy stated clearly. Alternative payment options to reduce friction.
  • 07ActivationGets confirmation that the account is active.
  • 08OnboardingSets up a profile, with one goal: reach value quickly.
  • 09RetentionRegular value, engagement nudges, renewal, churn prevention, pause and win-back.

What changes

AspectTodayProposed
Membership levelsFour: unregistered, free site, trial, premiumThree: unregistered, freemium, premium
Registered free memberDoes not existFreemium: registered but not subscribed
Free trial4 weeks, as its own level7 days, inside the premium level
Card detailsAsked for when upgradingAsked for at sign-up, not charged during the trial
When the trial endsNeeds a decision to upgradeContinues to paid unless cancelled
If they don't continueBack to the free siteStays a freemium member

Registration now creates a lasting freemium account, the middle state the Australian flow was missing. Asking for a card at sign-up raises the stakes for the user, so the checkout is explicit about trial conditions, the renewal date and how to cancel, and cancelling keeps the person as a freemium member instead of losing them.

Four journeys to prototype

Before designing screens, I wrote the redesign as four connected day-in-the-life journeys, one per level. Each has a theme, a core user story, five scenes, the point it has to prove to stakeholders, and the key screens to prototype. Together they set one rule for every screen that followed.

The rule

Morningstar grows with me, not Morningstar is four separate products.

Prototype flows board: four columns for Visitor, Free sign-in, Investor Premium and Investor Pro, each with a theme, core user story, entry point, five scenes, a stakeholder point and the key screens to prototype
The prototype flows board: four journeys, one per level

Visitor

Anonymous

"I heard about a stock, fund or ETF and want to know if Morningstar can help me make sense of it."

Discover → trust → sample value → sign up

  • Search or referral landing page
  • Instrument detail page
  • Comparison teaser
  • Sign-up gate

Free

Registered

"I want to keep an eye on my investments and get more relevant information without paying yet."

Track → personalise → build habit → feel the need for more

  • Welcome and onboarding
  • Personalised signed-in home
  • Watchlist creation
  • Alerts set-up
  • Upgrade moment

Premium

Investor

"I'm actively managing my money and want Morningstar to help me make better, more confident decisions."

Analyse → compare → decide → monitor

  • Premium dashboard
  • Portfolio diagnostics
  • Deep comparison page
  • AI decision support panel
  • Save, follow and alert confirmation

Pro

Advanced, SMSF, power users

"I'm a sophisticated investor and need a powerful, efficient workspace to run my investment process."

Research workspace → deep control → efficient decision system

  • Pro workspace home
  • Advanced screener
  • Saved strategy and results
  • Deep research view
  • AI workspace side panel
  • Export, report and save

Each journey ends where the next begins. The visitor hits a gate and creates a free account. The free member feels the need for more and meets the upgrade moment. The Premium member's comparison leads into the deeper workspace of Pro. The screens in the next section are these journeys, drawn.

The interface

I designed Investor Pro as a grid: every tool, at every membership level, in every state. I defined the component library first, then designed the screens from it at three sizes: the account and visitor pages, the editorial pages, the four tools at each level, and the navigation that holds them together. The article page went through to development first.

100+

screens, at large, medium and small sizes

5

levels: visitor, Free, Premium, Pro and Enterprise

370+

components in the library

One tool, five levels

Read each row from left to right. A visitor meets a locked page with a way in. A free member gets a working tool with some features held back. The paid levels open it up, and Enterprise adds governance: shared lists with a draft and published status. The layout never moves. Only the depth changes.

Visitor

Free

Premium

Pro

Enterprise

Screener

Screener for Visitor: a locked page with a way to sign in or create an account
Screener for Free: a working table with saving and ratings locked
Screener for Premium: the full table with ratings
Screener for Pro: the full table for professional use
Screener for Enterprise: the full table used to build approved product lists

Watchlist

Watchlist for Visitor: a locked page with a way to sign in or create an account
Watchlist for Free: one list with a limit of ten securities
Watchlist for Premium: several lists, with a limit and a prompt to upgrade
Watchlist for Pro: unlimited lists
Watchlist for Enterprise: a shared list with a draft status
Two tools at five levels. Select any screen to see it full size.

Same tool, different job

The words change with the audience. An investor is looking for opportunities, an adviser is supporting advice, and a practice is governing a product list.

LevelScreenerWatchlist
InvestorDiscover investment opportunities that match your goalsBuild your list of investments to keep track of market movements
ProSearch and filter investments efficiently to support your advice processConstruct your defensible product list
EnterpriseBuild and maintain approved product listsTrack investments from research through governance, and publish approved product lists

Testing the Screener

I ran usability sessions on the new Screener with 12 people, six advisers and six investors, with the product manager, the lead developer and a customer success manager sitting in. Each person worked through four tasks: move between investment types, find a filter, search for a security, and move between tab groups. We also asked them to compare it with the screener they use today.

98%

of tasks completed

3.98

out of 5 satisfaction, average of the participants who rated it

88

SUS score, against 69 for ARC and 59 for Investor

Evaluation metrics summary: 98% task completion, 3.98 participant rating, time to learn moderately fast, navigation no major issue, language a minor issue for one participant, speed of task performance moderately fast
The summary from the usability test: time to learn and speed were moderately fast, navigation had no major issue, and language was a minor issue for one participant

The six advisers, all ARC users, were clear about what ARC lacked overall, not only in the screener.

The six investors ranged from beginners to people who do their own analysis in Excel. Like the advisers, most of what they raised was about the current site, not only the screener.

What people told us, and what it changed:

Both groups

Everything on one screen

The thing people liked most was not jumping between pages. Filters stay on the left and results update in place.

Advisers

More data, and a way out

Advisers wanted more columns on one screen, export to a spreadsheet, and saved screens with alerts. Column choice, export and saved screens went into the Pro level.

Investors

Plain words

Beginners stumbled on terms like "investment screener" and "capital allocation". Labels were rewritten and short explanations added where a term could not be avoided.

Investors

Speed and control

People wanted more rows per page, links that open in a new tab, and to compare the securities they had selected. Compare from a selection became part of the design.

Four ways to hold something back

A tiered product depends on how it says no. I used four patterns, from the strongest to the lightest. Each one names what is behind the lock and offers the way to open it.

Three states for every tool

Each tool is designed for the first visit, the return visit and the working view. The first visit explains the tool and offers one action. The return visit opens on saved work.

Joining and upgrading

Sign-up is one short form. The plans page changes with who is looking: a visitor sees Free, Premium and Pro, a free member sees their current plan marked, and a Premium member sees Premium, Pro and Enterprise.

Reading and research

Editorial pages keep one structure for visitors and members. Members get a darker header, the AI assistant in the navigation, and a prompt to upgrade in place of the prompt to join.

Adding investments

There are four ways to add investments to a watchlist: search, a saved screen, paste, or a file. The file import reports exactly what happened: everything added, some skipped as duplicates, or errors to fix.

The add investments panel in eleven states: search, selected results, from a saved screen, paste, file upload, loading, and import results with successes, duplicates and errors
The add investments panel in each of its states

Compare

Investments can be compared in columns or in rows, and whole portfolios can be compared with each other.

Portfolio X-ray

The overview shows value, performance and holdings. X-ray looks inside: risk score, regions, asset allocation and returns. Holdings can be edited in a side panel without leaving the analysis.

Inside the adviser's software

The same analysis runs inside the planning software advisers already use. It works across a client's accounts: one account, several side by side, or all of them combined.

Navigation

One navigation serves every level, as a full panel, a collapsed rail and a bottom bar on a phone. The More menu lists what each plan unlocks, so the navigation also explains the product.

Small screens

Pages and tools are designed at three sizes. On a phone the side panel becomes a bottom bar, and tables keep their key columns and scroll sideways for the others.

Built as a system

Every screen is assembled from one library: charts, tables and editorial blocks, plus the parts each tool is built from, such as the Screener's filter sets and slide-outs, the Watchlist's panels, and the navigation menus. That makes five levels affordable to build and maintain, because the difference between levels is configuration and not new design.

The Figma design file

Everything above lives in one Figma file, laid out as a grid: tools in columns, membership levels in rows, and the account, editorial and component sections around them. Anyone on the team can find a screen by asking two questions: which tool, and which level.

Overview of the whole Investor Pro Figma file: page components and layouts, tool-specific components and the component library on the left; sign up, sign in, upgrade, visitor and editorial pages in the middle; and the tools laid out with a column for each tool and a row for each membership level on the right
The whole design file at a glance

09 · Outcome

Where it stands

By July 2026 four modules had been built and released: the Screener, the Watchlist, Compare and the article page. Two measures moved while I was there: the System Usability Scale score rose from 59 to 88, and the Net Promoter Score from 29 to 67. I left Morningstar that month, before the growth, retention and conversion results were in. What I can show is what the work left behind and what the team set out to measure.

What the work left behind

What the team set out to measure

Operational complexity first: fewer duplicate features and systems. Then user outcomes: engagement across research journeys, retention and renewals, conversion to paid plans, and less drop-off in key workflows. Each level also carried its own primary measure, from conversion to a free account at the top of the funnel to retention at the Pro level.

What I learned

Get the research in before the screens, not after. The navigation test arrived near the end and showed that people were confident and wrong about our labels. Had it run three months earlier, the first round of screens would have carried better words, and the team would have argued less about structure.

Five advisers is a sample, not an answer. We treated their results as directional, which was right, but it left the biggest open question of the project, whether navigation should change by role, unresolved when I left. Next time I would recruit the harder audience first and accept a slower start.

The premortem was the most useful hour of the project. The team named the fear that the levels would feel the same before a single screen existed, and that fear shaped the gating patterns, the wording per level and the plans page. I would run one on every project, and earlier.