Back

Investor Pro

Morningstar Australia · Two paid products into one

I was the product designer on a team of nine at Morningstar Australia. My audit and comparisons helped the team see how much our two paid research products overlapped, and we designed one product with five membership levels. Four modules were built and released before I left, and in sessions I ran with advisers and investors the new Screener scored 88 on the System Usability Scale, against 69 and 59 for the two existing products. The full case study has every board, study and screen.

Investor Pro: the Screener results table in front of the plans page, with smaller pieces around them: a download failed message, an empty watchlist, an actions menu, an allocation bar and a price sparkline
My role
Senior Designer: discovery, workshops, design and testing
Company
Morningstar Australia
Team
Nine people across business, product, domain experts, engineering and design
Timeline
Aug 2025 to Jul 2026

Background

Morningstar is the number one independent investment research company in Australia. It had two paid research products. Morningstar Investor is for people who do their own research and track their own portfolio. Adviser Research Centre, or ARC, is for financial advisers, who use it to search and compare investments, keep watchlists and build model portfolios.

Growth in both products was in single digits, 6% for ARC and 8% for Morningstar Investor, and trending down. The business wanted double-digit growth, members who stay, and free users who convert to paid.

Whiteboard with handwritten notes. Opportunity: double digit growth. Problem: too expensive to grow, resources and products. Challenge: is it two separate products
A whiteboard from one of our workshops. The opportunity was double-digit growth, the problem was that we were too expensive to grow, and the challenge was whether we had two separate products.

My role

I was the product designer on a team of nine: a business owner, product, adviser and investor experts, engineering and architecture. I joined before the project formally started, because I had worked on Australian financial planning products before.

I ran the team's workshops, audited our sites, compared us with the market and mapped the membership flows. I designed the journeys and screens, and I ran the research: a card sort, a navigation test and the usability sessions on the new Screener.

Framing workshopFraming workshop
Audit of six sitesAudit of six sites
Site mapsSite maps
31 products compared31 products compared
Current flow, AustraliaCurrent flow, Australia
Current flow, with screensCurrent flow, with screens
Current flow, globalCurrent flow, global
Personas and packagingPersonas and packaging
Day in the lifeDay in the life
SailboatSailboat
PremortemPremortem
Proposed flowProposed flow
Task flowTask flow
Wire flowWire flow
Visual flowVisual flow
Prototype flowsPrototype flows
Card sortCard sort
Card sort, similarityCard sort, similarity
Proposed navigationProposed navigation
Navigation testNavigation test
Navigation test, by taskNavigation test, by task
Boards from the workshops and flow mapping, with slides from the two navigation studies. Each one opens full size.

How we got to one product

We started by looking closely at what we had, and at similar products in other markets.

I put six Morningstar sites on one board: three in Australia (two paid, one public) and three from other markets. It held about 400 navigation items. The three Australian sites organised the same content three ways: by topic, by task and by asset class.

The full audit board: site maps on the left, site journeys, a tools and offering comparison, screenshots of global sites, and card sort labels
The audit board: six sites, side by side.

As we looked closer, we found three signs that the two products were converging.

Overlap

The same features

Advisers used almost the same functions as investors, with more advanced tools.

Price

Advisers on the cheaper product

ARC cost more, and many advisers who cared more about research than tools bought Morningstar Investor instead.

Cost

Two of everything

Two products meant two teams, two development cycles and two sets of designs, which made them too expensive to grow.

There had been no plan to merge the products. Partway through the research we decided to build one product for both audiences, Investor Pro. My part was the audit and the comparisons, which helped the team see how much the two shared.

One product, five levels

One product had to serve a first-time visitor and an advice practice. To see where growth could come from, I compared Morningstar Investor with 30 other products across traffic, research, data, editorial, investment products and membership.

17

analysts, the most of the 31 products compared

338K

visits a month, against 2.2M for The Motley Fool

$675

a year: one price, and no free membership

The research was good, and too few people reached it. I also mapped the Australian path from visitor to paying member. A person was anonymous, on a four-week trial, or paying, so someone whose trial ended had no account to keep.

Those two findings shaped the first two levels. A visitor needs real value before paying, and Australia needed a free account that people keep.

The first sketch of the levels was free trial, investor and adviser. That would have recreated separate products inside one. We settled on five levels of one product: Visitor, Free, Premium, Pro and Enterprise.

The navigation and the layout stay the same at every level, and each level opens more of the tools and research. For each level the team wrote what the member wants and one business measure.

Visitor

"Can I trust this?"

Open editorial and locked tools, measured by conversion to a free account.

Free

"Is this useful for me?"

Working tools with limits, measured by engagement and upgrade.

Premium

"Help me make better decisions."

Analyst ratings and deeper tools, measured by retention and deeper use.

Pro and Enterprise

"I need professional-grade tools."

Tools for the advice process and shared product lists, measured by retention.

Where we wanted to go, and what could stop us

With a first version of the levels drafted, I ran two sessions with the team: a sailboat and a premortem.

FigJam sailboat board: a boat sailing towards an island marked Goal, with an anchor labelled What slows us down, rocks labelled Risks on the horizon, and a sun labelled Opportunities, each with sticky notes
The sailboat board: the goal, the opportunity, the risks ahead and what slows us down.

The island

The goal

A platform for both audiences that devalues neither, with a soft transition for ARC users.

The sun

The opportunity

AI built into the whole product, not added as a feature.

The rocks

Risks ahead

Paid does not feel valuable, and the downgrade path is unclear.

The anchor

What slows us down

An unclear scope, and dependence on the global site.

In the premortem, we imagined the product had launched and failed, and everyone wrote down why. We got 36 reasons in three themes and cast 38 votes. The top worry was that the levels would not feel different enough.

FigJam board with three groups of sticky notes from the premortem, marked with thumbs-up, star and plus-one votes
The premortem board, with the team's votes.

Four of the top worries changed the design.

4 votes

Levels might not feel different

Each level got its own purpose, measure and wording, and I designed four ways for the product to hold features back.

3 votes

Advisers might lack professional tools

Pro and Enterprise became levels in their own right, built around the advice process.

3 votes

Clients not told about the change

One navigation, one look and a free level keep the change small, and the business owned the communication plan.

3 votes

Requirements keep changing

Every screen is built from one set of components, so a level can change without a redesign.

The design

The product was too big to deliver in one go. We broke it into modules and worked on them in phases, with one vision across all of them. By the time I left, the Screener, the Watchlist, Compare and the article page had been built and released.

Becoming a member

In the proposed membership path, registering creates a free account you keep. The trial moves inside Premium and drops from four weeks to seven days.

The trial asks for a card, which is a bigger commitment for the user. So in the flow I designed, the checkout states the trial conditions, the renewal date and how to cancel. Cancelling leaves you as a free member.

A visitor meets a locked page with a way to create a free account. Sign-up is one short form.

One tool across the levels

A visitor sees a locked Screener. A Free member gets a working Screener, with analyst ratings and saving held back, so the reason to upgrade is visible inside the tool. Premium opens the ratings. Pro adds column choice and export, and an Enterprise practice uses the same table to build approved product lists.

The Screener for a visitor, a Free member, a Premium member and an Enterprise practice. The layout stays the same.

The wording changes with the audience. For an investor the Screener says "Discover investment opportunities that match your goals". For a practice it says "Build and maintain approved product lists".

Four ways to hold a feature back

This was my answer to the premortem's top worry. I designed four ways to hold something back, from strongest to lightest: a locked page, a blurred preview, a locked feature and a visible limit. Each one shows what is behind the lock and how to open it.

The four ways, strongest first.

What users told us

The Screener sessions I ran

I ran usability sessions on the new Screener with 12 people: six advisers who use ARC and six investors. Each person did four tasks and compared the new Screener with the one they use today. The product manager, the lead developer and a customer success manager sat in on the sessions, and afterwards they agreed to add the data advisers had asked for.

98%

of tasks completed

3.98

out of 5 for satisfaction, from the participants who rated it

88

on the System Usability Scale (SUS), against 69 for ARC and 59 for Morningstar Investor

The six advisers, all ARC users, were clear about what ARC lacked overall, not only in the screener.

The six investors ranged from beginners to people who do their own analysis in Excel. Like the advisers, most of what they raised was about the current site, not only the screener.

Both groups

Everything on one screen

What people liked most was not jumping between pages: filters and results share one screen.

Advisers

More data, and export

They asked for more columns, spreadsheet export and saved screens with alerts, so column choice and export went into Pro.

Investors

Plain words

Beginners stumbled on terms such as capital allocation, so we rewrote labels and added short explanations.

Navigation research

I ran two studies on the navigation. In the card sort, 36 investors and five advisers grouped 28 menu labels taken from my audit. Both groups agreed on Markets, both mixed up Investments and Research, and both asked for a Learn section without being offered one.

In the navigation test, 27 investors did seven tasks using only the menu labels.

74%

went straight to an answer

36%

got it right, against a 70% benchmark

1 of 7

tasks passed: upcoming dividends

The navigation test summary and the proposed navigation.

Together the studies pointed to six sections: Markets, My Portfolio, News and Analysis, Discover and Research, Learn, and utility tools. People were confident and wrong, so we kept the structure and rewrote the labels in the user's words. In the screens I separated Watchlist and Screener from Portfolio.

Advisers started from research and investors from news, but five advisers were too few to decide on. I did not build a separate adviser navigation, and one navigation serves every level.

The design system

Morningstar's design system had basic elements and a few components, with no page layouts and only basic table behaviour. We built a set of components and page layouts on top of it: tables, filters, navigation and charts. Other Morningstar products later used the same set, including AdviserLogic and Morningstar UK.

I designed the Investor Pro screens from that set: more than 100 screens at three sizes, from more than 370 components. I laid out the Figma file as a grid, with tools in columns and levels in rows, so anyone on the team can find a screen.

Overview of the whole Investor Pro Figma file: page components and layouts, tool-specific components and the component library on the left; sign up, sign in, upgrade, visitor and editorial pages in the middle; and the tools laid out with a column for each tool and a row for each membership level on the right
The design file, with components on the left and the tools by level on the right.

Outcome

By July 2026 four modules had been built and released: the Screener, the Watchlist, Compare and the article page. Two measures moved while I was there. The new Screener scored 88 on the System Usability Scale in sessions with 12 advisers and investors, against 69 for ARC and 59 for Morningstar Investor. The Net Promoter Score rose from 29 to 67.

The work left the team one direction in place of two products, with five membership levels and a free level Australia did not have. It also left a proposed membership path with clear terms at checkout, rewritten navigation labels and one component set.

I left Morningstar in July 2026, before the growth, retention and conversion results were in.

What I learned

I would run a premortem on every project. The team named its biggest worry early, and that worry led to the four ways of holding a feature back.

I would push for the navigation research before the screens. The navigation test arrived near the end, and three months earlier it would have given the first screens better labels.

I would also recruit advisers first. Five could not tell us whether navigation should change by role, and that question was still open when I left.